CARFAX vs AutoCheck

Are you stuck in a rut trying to decide which VIN decoder to use? We understand this can be a difficult position to be in but one that makes or breaks your financial standing. One wrong decision, and you could get a car that eats away at your money. Using a VIN decoder which provides you with all the necessary information to make this decision is important.

Two of the most acclaimed and widely used VIN check websites are CARFAX and AutoCheck. This article will compare the two and see which is a better pick.

From $34.99 per report
4.5 rating
Ranks #6 out of 22 companies
From $24.99 per report
4.5 rating
Ranks #5 out of 22 companies
CARFAX vs AutoCheck

Benefits of CARFAX

CARFAX provides its users with significant help when they are buying used cars. Let us look at some benefits of using it.

  • CARFAX has been around for a long time, so all the information is credible and accurate.
  • The sources used by CARFAX extend beyond official sources. The network of sources is huge.
  • CARFAX is very reliable.

Benefits of AutoCheck

The benefits of employing AutoCheck to check the used vehicle you are buying are listed below.

  • Inexpensive as compared to other VIN decoders.
  • Provides adequate information and is credible.
  • They provide a free AutoCheck score.
  • AutoCheck has data for other comparable cars that are for sale.

Quality Breakdown

We have discussed in detail all the components of the VIN decoders mentioned.


For a CARFAX report, you would have to pay $39.99 for one, and the highest number you can buy is ten for $99. On the other hand, AutoCheck is relatively inexpensive. An AutoCheck report for one vehicle costs $24.99. This comes close to the price of CARFAX. However, a bulk package of 300 AutoCheck vehicle history reports costs only $99.99, the same price for which you could get only ten CARFAX reports.

What's Included?

We have made a table that includes all the points from a checklist of items that need to be contained in a car history report. This table shows whether CARFAX and AutoCheck have these items.

Technical InformationYesYes
Accident HistoryYesYes - but limited
Ownership HistoryYesYes
Maintenance RecordsYesNo
Insurance DataYesYes
Registration DataYesYes
Theft ReportsYesYes

Additional Information

CARFAX provides no additional information apart from the vehicle history report, while AutoCheck provides extra information about the vehicle as well. AutoCheck gives you a list of other cars that have the same AutoCheck score as the vehicle you are interested in. Moreover, it shows you similar vehicles for sale — another useful feature for the users.

Resources Used

Both CARFAX and AutoCheck use an extensive network of sources. Their sources report information related to accidents, damages, and maintenance. The difference in the number of resources used is very insignificant.

How to Choose?

Autocheck is a strong competitor of CARFAX, and they both come close when it comes to the data that they provide users with. Autocheck is cheaper and provides customers with the same tools at a fraction of the price. However, if CARFAX resonates with you more, you could choose that option as it is more reliable.

Editors Choice
5.0 rating
From $12.79 per report
Use discount code: vinmentor
Ranks #1 out of 22 companies
5.0 rating
From $14.99 per report
Ranks #2 out of 22 companies
4.8 rating
From $14.99 per report
Ranks #3 out of 22 companies
4.5 rating
From $9.99 per report
Ranks #4 out of 22 companies